How to Write Plot Twists in a Cozy Mystery that Readers Will Love (Without Cheating)


Plot Twists Through Dialogue Misdirection: Misleading through dialogue can occur at any point in your cozy mystery and can be effective if not overly obvious.

Writers can introduce the first misdirection early to help embed the falsehood as a truth in the reader’s mind.

Plot Twist Through Clues: I like to embed clues within descriptions, but only one or two, if any.

Practice selectivity in these choices, and your impact will be stronger.

Red Herrings: I like planting false clues or paths that lead to dead ends (pun intended) because that makes me feel impish.

How can the pebbles in the vase be made of only glass?

Did the green ink stains on work coveralls really happen when a pen exploded inside their pocket? 

Plot Twist Solves the Puzzle:

”Ah-ha moments…”

Exterior Plot Twists: I’ve included a chart below to serve as a springboard for adding exterior plot twists.

These are natural fears that generate empathy for the central character.

Similar Posts

  • Letting a Story Rest

    MAKING YOUR STORY’S IMPACT MORE COMPELLING Skill-Building Craft Notes:Story Structures can include a Beat Sheet, which in turn guides your ability to pace your…

  • Conestoga Queen

    Kate Gordan’s teacher, Miss Allie, generously set aside large blocks of time for her class to get ready to go home. Kate…

  • Conflicts in Cozy Mysteries

    HOW CONFLICTS IN COZY MYSTERIES ARE LIKE COMPETING PLANTS: Conflict within cozy mysteries sounds stressful. Cozy mystery conventions say we create comforting,…

  • Three Clear Gifts

    This past weekend provided three of the best gifts. They won’t wear out, fall out of fashion, and they grow in value.  …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *